Two unique legal theories used to build clergy sexual abuse cases
Racketeering and public nuisance can be used to help hold a clergy member liable for sexual abuse.
A series of new lawsuits against clergy accused of sexual abuse are moving forward in California. These lawsuits are based on the legal theories of racketeering and nuisance to force bishops to provide lists of offenders and hold offenders accountable for their wrongdoing.
Racketeering laws and allegations of clergy abuse
The government commonly uses charges of racketeering to bring down mafia organizations. The legal argument in this case is that the Catholic church has acted as a criminal organization and thus violated the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO). Congress enacted RICO to combat organized crime throughout the country. A successful RICO claim allows the prosecution to hold leaders of criminal organizations liable for crimes they either ordered others to commit, assisted in committing or for furthering the ongoing criminal organization.
The strategy includes allegations the church first subjected children to abuse and then furthered their criminal actions by actively working to cover up the crimes in order to further its “commercial operations.”
This legal strategy has found success in the past. A victim of sexual abuse by a clergy member successfully built a case around this legal theory in 1993. This recent case is unique, because it also uses a strategy otherwise reserved for cases involving attempts to hold senior officers in the military responsible for wrongdoing referred to as the “command responsibility” doctrine.
Public nuisance and the need to release the names of credibly accused clergy members
The second attempt aims to use nuisance laws to establish the church has created a hazard to the public. A case out of Minnesota was able to proceed with a similar claim, noting much less harmful situations have warranted public nuisance claims in the past – cases like harboring a worrisome dog. The victim used this legal theory to demand the release of the names of priests who were abusing children.
In the more recent case, the claim could also result in the release of the names of the accused as well as help encourage negotiation of a settlement for the victims.
The legal strategy often depends on state laws
Although it is yet unknown whether these cases will find success with these claims, victims can benefit from keeping apprised of how courts respond to these claims. If others find success, they may as well.
It is also important to note that each state has its own laws. RICO statutes are one example. Although they are often similar to the federal RICO law, they have their own nuances. This piece touches on two recent cases brought in California as well as previous cases in both New Jersey and Minnesota. State laws are available to help victims in any state build a claim, but it is important to navigate these laws wisely. As such, a victim is wise to seek the counsel of an attorney experienced in this niche area of the law to better ensure his or her case is built based on applicable legal theories.
Verdicts and Settlements
Verdict of $88,000,000
Settlement of $12-Million
Settlement of $10-Million
NEGLIGENT SECURITY HOMICIDE
Verdict of $1.75-Million
Verdict of $1.53-Million
Settlement of $1.4-Million
Ben and Nate are great guys. They walked me through the whole process, from beginning til the end. The receptionist and very nice. Answer all my questions and concerns. I will refer them to anyone. Their not like other lawyers that talk around the topic. They tell you just how it is or how they believe it will be. Thank you guys so much.
Ben and Nate took their time in handling my case with compassion and care. I never had to wonder what was going on. They always made sure to include me in each and every decision that needed to be made before they were made. Their entire staff was always very polite and knowledgeable. I cannot say enough kind words about Andreozzi + Foote; they are simply the best!
One of the best personal injury lawyers in the country. Great experience. Really genuine people at Andreozzi and Associates.
Handled our case SO well even though it took a long time to settle, and STILL helps us with paperwork related to the settlement account every now and then. They were honest with us from the get-go, worked REALLY hard on our behalf, and always kept in touch with us about what was going on. So pleased.
When you and your child are victims of a horrid crime it’s hard to understand why things are the way they are. Information and answers are what you want, but unfortunately the system doesn’t offer that. Nathaniel has fielded and patiently listened to a broken mother wanting nothing more than for someone to help her understand why she has no answers, and through these phone calls Nathaniel has been very informative, honest and upfront. I would recommend Nathaniel and this firm to anyone who is seeking answers, help and professionalism in a firm when going through such difficult times.
Can’t say enough about the kindness and compassion of this law office. They helped me immensely with a difficult case and the level of support they provided me was stellar.
It is impossible to put into words our gratitude for Ben and Nate through the most trying time of our life. As scared, confused, and traumatized parents, the isolation and loneliness of litigation are abysmal. In the beginning, everyone surrounding you has endless bright ideas and can’t say enough how you should pursue action, but then when it comes down to it, these cheerleaders are suddenly silent and nowhere to be found in what feels to be your darkest hour. Thank God we had these two extraordinary men at our side from the moment we contacted them. Their friendship, counsel, and sound resolve to do everything they could in order to balance the scorecard meant more than we can ever convey, and is simply immeasurable. If we had known how simple this seemingly horrific ordeal would’ve been with their help from the start, we wouldn’t have agonized a single minute over doing what we did. If you are in a similar position as I’ve described, take advice from someone who’s been through the worst, thankfully with the best. Call them!