FREE CONFIDENTIAL CONSULTATION
FREE CONFIDENTIAL CONSULTATION

Pennsylvania Child Sexual Abuse Window

Pennsylvania is expected to eliminate the statute of limitations for sex abuse cases in early 2027. Contact Andreozzi + Foote now for a free, confidential consultation.

ANDREOZZI + FOOTE

Former Youth Pastor David J. Baird of Covenant Church of Pittsburgh | Convicted Sexual Abuser 

Composite image of former Covenant Church of Pittsburgh youth pastor David J. Baird, convicted of sexually abusing three boys, alongside a photograph of the church building in Pennsylvania.
Andreozzi + Foote Logo
Published by: Maria Smith

Key Takeaways

  • David John Baird, a former youth pastor at Covenant Church of Pittsburgh, was convicted in May 2008 of sexual offenses involving three boys. 
  • He was sentenced to 25 to 50 years in prison.
  • Baird also ran a ministry called David’s Refuge, and worked as a counselor at Pressley Ridge School. 
  • Andreozzi + Foote is investigating potential institutional responsibility in this case.

Former Youth Pastor David J. Baird Convicted of Child Sexual Abuse

David John Baird, a former youth pastor at Covenant Church of Pittsburgh, was convicted in May 2008 of multiple sexual offenses involving three boys who had encountered him through his religious ministry.

According to the Pittsburgh Post Gazette, “Mr. Baird worked for the church from January 1994 to 2004 as both a youth pastor and evangelical pastor.”

Baird was initially charged after two former youth ministry participants reported him sexually abusing them during weekend retreats to his Penn Hills residence.

A third victim subsequently came forward with allegations involving a community-service assignment supervised by Baird.

These criminal cases resulted in convictions for multiple sexual offenses.

Survivors Reported Years of Sexual Abuse by David Baird

Baird reportedly assaulted two victims from 1997 to 2003. 

According to a June 25, 2007 Pittsburgh Post-Gazette report, one victim reported that Baird began sexually abusing him when he was approximately 9 or 10 years old until he was about 17 or 18. The survivor testified Baird had sexually assaulted him “20 to 40 times over the years.”

“Mr. Baird was youth minister at Covenant Church of Pittsburgh in Wilkinsburg in 1999 when an East Hills boy, the first to file a complaint, was recruited to participate in programs,” the Post-Gazette reported.

According to the Post-Gazette, “The teen testified that the assaults began during one of the frequent sleep-overs at Mr. Baird’s Orchard Drive home in Penn Hills. Though other youths and the suspect’s family were at home each time, he said Mr. Baird would come to him in the family room of the large home where the boy slept away from the others.” 

A second boy reported that Baird sexually assaulted him on approximately six occasions at the same residence. The abuse began when the boy was 14 years old.

Baird initially faced 20 criminal charges across these first two cases. The charges included:

  • Involuntary deviate sexual intercourse with a person under 16
  • Indecent assault
  • Sexual assault
  • Statutory sexual assault
  • Indecent exposure
  • Endangering the welfare of children
  • Corruption of minors
  • Unlawful contact with a minor for

Three additional counts of involuntary deviate sexual intercourse with a person under 16 were later added to the second case, bringing the total to 23 charges across the first two cases.

Third Victim Came Forward 

A third victim came forward later. According to a May 2008 Pittsburgh Post-Gazette report, “the third alleged victim told investigators that he was on juvenile probation in 2002, and had been ordered to perform community service in Wilkinsburg with Mr. Baird as his supervisor.

Instead of working on the assigned project, the boy said in a sworn affidavit, Mr. Baird drove him to Friendship Park in Penn Hills. The boy said he was ‘shocked, afraid and offended’ as Mr. Baird molested him. The youth said the assault ended only after he began to cry out in pain.” 

The allegations resulted in a third criminal case against Baird, involving charges of indecent assault of a person under 13 and corruption of minors.

Survivors Describe Betrayal of Trust

During Baird’s criminal proceedings, survivors described how he exploited their trust in him as a religious mentor. He was referred to as both a spiritual guide and a tormentor.

At a June 2007 preliminary hearing, one victim testified, “‘He would go on a guilt trip…We would actually pray and ask God to forgive him and me for allowing it to happen.’”

According to a July 31, 2008 Pittsburgh Post-Gazette article, “All three [survivors] testified that after Mr. Baird assaulted them, he would begin to cry and ask for forgiveness, and then they would pray together.” 

During Baird’s sentencing hearing, one survivor explained that he had considered Baird a father figure.

The survivor testified that after confiding in Baird about uncertainty surrounding his sexuality, Baird exploited that information and his trust in God. He said that “when he confided in Mr. Baird that he was confused about his sexuality, the relationship turned. ‘That information that I gave him, he abused it,” said the victim. ‘He took advantage of my trust in him and my trust in God.’”

David J. Baird Sentenced to 25–50 Years in Prison

On July 30, 2008, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge John A. Zottola sentenced Baird to an aggregate 25 to 50 years in prison for the sexual offenses involving the three victims.

Baird maintained his innocence and declined to address the court.

According to Allegheny County court records, the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed Baird’s sentences on October 29, 2009. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court subsequently denied his petition for allowance of appeal in January 2011.

According to Pennsylvania Department of Corrections reviewed on November 18, 2026, David John Baird, 64, DOB 04/14/1962, remains incarcerated at State Correctional Institution Forest (SCI Forest) in Marienville, Pennsylvania. SCI Forest is a maximum security prison for adult males.

Covenant Church’s Response

Following Baird’s arrest, a Covenant Church spokesperson told KDKA Pittsburgh: “‘Covenant Church of Pittsburgh is committed to caring for and protecting every minor entrusted to our care. Like all staff and volunteers at CCOP, Mr. Baird did pass a Pennsylvania State Police criminal background check.’”

Although background checks are an important child-protection measure, they are not sufficient on their own to prevent sexual abuse. Individuals without a documented criminal history may obviously still pose a serious risk to children.

Who is Reverend David John Baird?

Before his criminal convictions, Reverend David John Baird spent more than a decade working with children and teenagers through religious ministries and youth-serving organizations in Pittsburgh and beyond. Given his subsequent convictions for sexually abusing three boys, the extent of his access to children through these positions is deeply concerning.

Covenant Church of Pittsburgh

Baird served as a youth pastor at Covenant Church for more than a decade, from 1994 through 2004, working with children and teenagers through youth ministry and evangelistic outreach.

Various National and International Ministries

An archived webpage from 1998 provides more detailed information on his background; “David Baird has ministered extensively in Mexico, the Netherlands and across the U.S. 

David’s heart for evangelism and youth has impacted the lives of many, rallying them to the call of reaching the lost. David serves as the Youth Minister at Covenant Church of Pittsburgh.”

In an archived webpage featuring a 1998 Covenant Church church newsletter, Baird is mentioned several times: 

“In June, Pastor David Baird will lead a team to Del Rio, Texas where they will join with Alan Ehlers and Faith Ministries International (FMI). FMI has ministered for more than 20 years to the Mexican people on the Texas border and they have developed a fine outreach that includes food distribution and evangelistic outreaches. ‘While this trip will include our CCOP youth,’ Pastor David explained, ‘it is open to anyone who wants to spend a week with a wonderful ministry doing a good work.”

“The W.O.W. ministry, led by Steven and Linda Tavani, will return to conduct an urban missions outreach from July 26 – August 3. Pastor David Baird and his team are currently planning where the outreaches will be held in Pittsburgh. ‘We will need many volunteers this year, not only to help with the outreach, but with the all-important follow up with those who give their lives to the Lord’, Pastor David pointed out.”

David’s Refuge

David’s Refuge was a ministry led by Baird that reportedly aided local children.

A Covenant Church staff directory also identifies Baird with David’s Refuge.

Pressley Ridge School

According to KDKA Pittsburgh, “Baird worked as a counselor at Pressley Ridge School on the North Side…A spokesperson for the school says they did a complete background check on Baird before they hired him and nothing came up and they didn’t have problems with him while he worked there.”

He reportedly resigned from the school in May 2007, but the exact dates of his employment are unknown.

Where Is David Baird Now?

According to Pennsylvania Department of Corrections records reviewed on November 18, 2026, David John Baird, 64, remains incarcerated at State Correctional Institution Forest (SCI Forest) in Marienville, Pennsylvania.

His date of birth is listed as April 14, 1962.

Spiritual Manipulation, Grooming, and DARVO

One of the many disturbing aspects of Baird’s case was his reported use of prayer following the sexual assaults that he perpetrated. 

According to one survivor, in his prayers, Baird asked God to forgive the children and himself.

The testimony raises serious concerns about spiritual manipulation and victim-blaming, as Baird appeared to place moral responsibility on children who bore no responsibility for his actions.

A related form of psychological manipulation is DARVO (Deny, Attack, and Reverse Victim and Offender). Coined by psychologist Jennifer Freyd, DARVO describes a pattern in which an accused individual denies wrongdoing, attacks the accuser’s credibility, and portrays themselves as the victim.

Victims of sexual abuse are never responsible for sexual abuse committed against them. 

Religious authority, guilt, and teachings about forgiveness should never be used to excuse abuse, discourage disclosure, or encourage the victim to feel guilty.

Church Ministry Raises Concerns About Its Approach to Sexual Abuse

Historical records from Covenant Church of Pittsburgh reveal troubling language used by Dunamis Ministries, a church program addressing “sexual brokenness” during Baird’s tenure. There is no established evidence that Baird participated in Dunamis Ministries, however the church’s language is disturbing.  

Particularly concerning is how the ministry discussed victims and perpetrators within the same framework of what they called “sexual brokeness:”

“We may be the victim or victimizer; we may even mutually consent with others in relationships fueled by sexual sin and brokeness. Regardless, we undermine the great gift of our sexuality.” 

The wording appears to blur the distinction between being a victim of sexual abuse and committing sexual abuse as a perpetrator. 

Experiencing sexual abuse is not a sin or moral failing, and survivors bear no responsibility for the abuse committed against them.

These ideologies raise questions about how the church as a whole approached sexual abuse disclosures and whether survivors were supported rather than being made to feel responsible for their victimization.

When Religious Institutions Become Safe Havens for Abusers

Churches and other religious institutions are meant to provide safety, guidance, and support. Unfortunately, however, in some religious environments, the church discourages survivors from reporting abuse in order to “protect” an institution’s reputation.

Although many religious organizations have strengthened child-protection policies, background checks and written safeguards alone are insufficient. Effective prevention requires ongoing supervision, independent reporting procedures, prompt responses to allegations, and accountability for leadership.

Religious institutions must ensure that protecting children and survivors takes precedence over preserving reputations and that forgiveness is never used to excuse abuse or silence survivors.

Could Covenant Church of Pittsburgh or Other Institutions Face Civil Liability?

When a religious leader entrusted with supervising children commits sexual abuse, civil responsibility may extend to the institution if negligence contributed to the harm.

An investigation involving Baird could examine:

  • Screening and supervision: Whether appropriate oversight and safeguards existed for youth activities, overnight retreats, and mentoring.
  • Prior warning signs: Whether church leaders or other administrators received complaints or reports of concerning behavior.
  • Child-protection policies: Whether appropriate abuse-prevention and mandatory reporting procedures were maintained and followed.

Civil investigations can help determine whether churches and religious institutions overlooked warning signs or otherwise contributed to preventable sexual abuse. Beyond seeking compensation for survivors, civil lawsuits can help hold religious institutions accountable and encourage stronger safeguards to protect children from future abuse.

Were You Sexually Abused by Rev. David J. Baird?

Survivors of child sexual abuse may have civil legal rights separate from criminal proceedings, including potential claims against churches, or other institutions who may have been  negligent.

Andreozzi + Foote represents survivors of child sexual abuse in Pennsylvania and nationwide, investigating potential claims involving religious organizations, schools, youth programs, and other institutions entrusted with children’s safety.

Andreozzi + Foote encourages anyone who sexually abused David J. Baird to contact our firm.

Our trauma-informed attorneys are available to listen and help you understand your legal rights and options.

All consultations are free and confidential.

📞 (866) 311-8640
📧 info@vca.law 

Image source: David J. Baird, via Inmate Locater. Covenant Church of Pittsburgh, via GCMSI.

Teddy Bear

Child Sexual Abuse Resource Guide

At Andreozzi + Foote we want the clients we serve and their families to feel empowered every step of the way. The issues surrounding child sexual abuse are complicated and highly emotional and everyone’s reasons for coming forward are deeply personal. 

Related Perpetrator

CONTACT US TODAY

Free In-Depth,
Confidential Consultation

Empowering Survivors and Delivering Justice Nationwide

We understand the courage it takes to reach out for help, and we are here to listen. At Andreozzi + Foote, our trauma-informed attorneys are dedicated to providing compassionate, confidential support every step of the way. With extensive experience in advocating for survivors of sexual abuse, we are committed to creating a safe and supportive environment where your voice is heard and your rights are fiercely protected. Contact us today for a free, in-depth consultation and take the first step toward justice.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.